Southeast Asia At High Risk For Arsenic Contamination In Water
ScienceDaily (July 14, 2008) — The contamination of groundwater with arsenic poses a risk to the health of millions of people, especially in the densely populated river deltas of Southeast Asia. To date, no method has been available for identifying high-risk areas without conducting costly sampling campaigns.
Now, Eawag has developed a model that allows vulnerable areas to be pinpointed using existing data on geology and soil properties. This has also enabled the researchers to detect high-risk areas in regions where groundwater studies had not previously been carried out, such as in Myanmar and on Sumatra.
Worldwide, more than 100 million people are exposed to excessive amounts of arsenic in drinking water. Arsenic is a geogenic contaminant – deriving from natural sources – which is dissolved in groundwater. In many areas, the problem is recognized, but because surface waters are polluted new wells are continually established, often without testing the pumped water for arsenic.
Making use of available data
In an article published in the journal Nature Geoscience, Eawag researchers have now described a method that allows high-risk areas to be identified relatively easily, without the need for expensive and time-consuming groundwater analysis. For this purpose, the team, led by geologist Lenny Winkel and environmental chemist Michael Berg, compiled existing geological data from Bangladesh, Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam and Sumatra (Indonesia) to produce a uniformly classified map.
The data related only to surface sediments and soil properties; surprisingly, this combination of data permits sufficiently accurate conclusions to be drawn concerning chemical and physical conditions in groundwater.
The scientists then studied the statistical relations between 30 surface parameters (geological, hydrological and climate data) and arsenic concentrations, and finally incorporated the eight most relevant variables into a logistic regression model. In particular, young river deposits with organic rich sediments proved to be indicators of groundwater arsenic contamination. This is apparent from the maps in which the probabilities calculated for elevated arsenic concentrations are presented in a graphical form.
Supporting governments and aid agencies
Verification of the model using more than 1750 available groundwater data points from the Bengal, Mekong and Red River deltas showed that the predictions accorded well with reality. However, in areas assigned a low risk by the model, the risk cannot be assumed to be zero. “There is no such thing,” as Michael Berg points out. The environmental chemist adds that, ultimately, even a refined model, e.g. including more data from deeper rock strata, could not serve as a substitute for analysis of water samples. “But thanks to the maps, governments, local authorities or aid agencies can tell very quickly where it might be problematic to sink a well.”
New high-risk areas detected on Sumatra and in Myanmar
The latest findings from Southeast Asia are part of the Water Resource Quality (WRQ) project, an Eawag research programme studying the occurrence of geogenic contaminants in groundwater worldwide. As well as arsenic, these include fluoride, selenium and uranium. In parallel, methods are being developed to allow the populations affected to treat contaminated water, using appropriate technologies. To date, work has been carried out on a very coarse scale, but this has now been successfully refined (up to 10x10 km) thanks to the project in Southeast Asia. The new model is of particular interest for regions where no groundwater measurement data are yet available.
Accordingly, the Swiss aquatic research team applied the model to the Indonesian island of Sumatra, where an area covering 100,000 km2 on the eastern coast was found to be at high risk for arsenic contamination. The researchers subsequently used about 100 groundwater samples to verify the probabilities predicted by the model for a region on the border between a low- and a high-risk area. Once again, the results of analyses were found to agree well with the predictions: 94% of the wells in the low-risk area showed arsenic concentrations below 10 µg/L. The maps also indicate an increased risk of elevated arsenic concentrations in groundwater in the Irrawaddy delta (Myanmar) and along the Chao Phraya river north of Bangkok (Thailand) – both areas where the risk had not previously been recognized.
Background Information on Arsenic
Arsenic is one of the most important inorganic contaminants found in drinking water. This metalloid occurs as a natural component of underground rocks worldwide, with small quantities being dissolved in groundwater as a result of weathering. The inorganic salts of arsenic are tasteless and odourless, but highly toxic to humans. If ingested over long periods, even low concentrations can cause damage to health, including hyperpigmentation of the skin, disorders of liver and kidney function, and various types of cancer.
Problems arise from the fact that firstly, arsenic concentrations can vary widely at the local level and, secondly, in many areas people are completely unaware of the risk because their well water or groundwater has never been tested for arsenic. Arsenic concentrations below 10 µg/L are deemed to be safe. This concentration is therefore recommended by the World Health Organization as a guideline value for arsenic in drinking water.
In the deltas of the Red River and the Mekong, Eawag detected arsenic concentrations exceeding 100 µg/L in one in five of the samples analysed, with maximum values as high as 3000 µg/L. In the Irrawaddy delta (Myanmar), a study supported by Unicef found arsenic concentrations of more than 50 µg/L at two thirds of the sampled wells.
Predicting groundwater arsenic contamination in Southeast Asia from surface parameters” / LENNY WINKEL, MICHAEL BERG*, MANOUCHEHR AMINI, STEPHAN J. HUG AND C. ANNETTE JOHNSON (all: Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, 8600 Du¨ bendorf, Switzerland) doi: 10.1038/ngeo254 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ngeo254
Lenny Winkel, Michael Berg, Manouchehr Amini, Stephan J. Hug And C. Annette Johnson. Predicting groundwater arsenic contamination in Southeast Asia from surface parameters. Nature Geoscience, 2008; DOI:
A Cambodian showing the effects of chronic arsenic poisoning. (Credit: Resource Development International-Cambodia)